City of Cleveland - Recommendations for an Arts-Inclusive City
The creative and cultural industries in Cleveland are a core part of our city’s success and vitality.
We define arts and culture in its broadest sense encompassing art forms ranging from traditional to contemporary. According to data from Creative Vitality Suite, in 2019, the City of Cleveland had 15,849 jobs by creative industries alone, generating $2.9b in sales within our local economy. While arts and culture drive economic growth and regional tourism, research also consistently reveals the positive influence the arts have on other sectors including education, healthcare, public safety, mental health, community revitalization and our region’s competitiveness in other markets.
Despite the facts, Cleveland is still one of the largest cities in the country that does not currently support or promote arts and culture in its government structure. A permanent infrastructure and City Arts and Culture Liaison with a clear set of goals and strategies, will allow our city to leverage the potential of our arts and cultural assets, as well as provide much–needed support and recognition for our creative workers. The mayor has publicly recognized the need for an arts-supportive infrastructure and we are confident this promise will be delivered on.
The following recommendations were developed with the arts and culture community, facilitated by Assembly for the Arts.
Create an Infrastructure in City Hall Dedicated to the Creative and Cultural Industries
Recommendations:
- Secure the right person for a cabinet-level position for arts and culture (see ROLES)
- Establish and work with an arts and culture community advisory group, comprised of individual artists and representatives of nonprofit organizations and creative businesses
- Recognize and leverage the work of current city staff dedicated to arts and culture. Establish an arts and culture line item in the administration’s budget to support the work outlined below
- Infuse arts and culture into the city’s committee structures and departments, such as community development, economic development, health and human services, public safety and education
Selecting an individual to lead these efforts within the administration will be critical. We recommend the establishment of an Arts and Culture Community Advisory group to supply necessary information about the local creative and cultural economy to aid the mayor in making informed decisions on potential candidates, as well as purpose and goal development for the Department of Cultural Affairs. To jumpstart this process, we recommend working with existing and established arts community coalitions including: Artist Bridge Coalition, Assembly for the Arts, Black Local Artists of Cleveland – Kuumba, Cleveland Arts Education Consortium, Collective Arts Network, National Independent Venue Association and Third Space Action Lab.
Budgeting will be equally important – developing a process to determine both the amount of available funding within the existing budget and how much will be needed to carry out the goals of the department is a necessary initial step.
Establish Purpose and Role of the Arts Infrastructure and Arts Liaison
The definition and title of the cabinet-level position will be important in setting the tone for the department and scope for which it will engage with, include and represent the community. Defining the department’s role(s) clearly will lay the groundwork for successful implementation of the Phase 4 work.
Recommendations: Select the best candidate
- Carefully consider the position title and how it will represent both community and city; consider traditional, non-traditional, contemporary and historic arts practices
- Ensure the candidate is deeply embedded and connected to the arts community
- Ensure the candidate has a strong understanding of DEI, BIPOC communities and Accessibility practices
- Ensure the candidate is equitable in their approach to the arts community
Recommendations: Define the Department’s Role
- Manage a coordinated effort to empower and promote the work of all Cleveland’s arts and culture stakeholders
- Oversee and manage the identity of Cleveland as an arts city
- Assist the mayor in developing an effective narrative about the power of the arts and their relationship to the city
- Coordinate and steward a downtown arts and culture district, which includes a cohesive and well-communicated programming agenda
Sanction and Execute a City Cultural Planning Process Driven by Cleveland’s Arts Communities
A key component of the newly developed city arts infrastructure will be the execution of a city-wide cultural planning process. This process will enable the city to identify needs, scope the landscape of the arts community and develop a set of strategies and tactics to support the arts community, leverage our creative and cultural assets and increase resident engagement with arts and culture.
Recommendations: Cultural Plan
- Establish a creative and cultural industry taskforce specified for this process
- Identify a research scope to launch the cultural plan process
1: Allocate ARPA funds to the arts and culture sector in 2022:
Allocating American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds to creative businesses, nonprofits and individual artists across the City of Cleveland who have been devastated by the COVID-19 pandemic will act as both a substantive and symbolic effort in the new administration’s support of the creative and cultural economy. We recommend working with Assembly for the Arts and Cuyahoga Arts & Culture to bring this funding distribution to fruition.
2: Center Arts and Culture in Racial Equity and Inclusion and Other City-wide Planning by:
2a. Integrate arts and culture into city task forces addressing Racism as a Public Health Crisis
2b. Integrate arts and culture into efforts around improving internal city affairs processes including government policies contributing to the systemic racism, siloed departments, city staff communications and morale, slow response rates for residents and others
2c. Partner with arts and cultural groups to enhance public safety efforts
2e. Prioritize neighborhood cultural preservation
3: Expand the City’s Definition of Arts and Culture:
Cleveland’s arts and culture sector and creative industries represent a broad range of individuals, cultures, institutions, organizations, disciplines, events and experiences. Recognizing and understanding the contributions that all parts of the creative ecosystem make to our city’s vibrancy, economic development and overall progress will be key when developing an effective narrative of Cleveland as an arts-rich city
3a. Include individual artists, creative for-profit businesses and arts and culture nonprofits in the city department scope of work
3b. Recognize an expanded range of creative disciplines in city-wide arts and culture planning decisions, including but not limited to craft, dance, design, film, literature, media, music, performance, theatre and visual arts
4: Develop a Cohesive Multi-Disciplinary Arts Programming Agenda including:
4a. Establish a City of Cleveland Artist in Residence program
4b. Sustain public art programming including funding for the established Mural My Neighborhood program
4c. Support BIPOC Creative workers through commissions, grants and fellowships
4d. Build a cohesive arts events communication structure. Continue and build upon arts programming from the prior administration
5: Elevate and Protect Creative Workers Driving Neighborhood Development:
The arts and culture communities have been core partners in the successful redevelopment of Cleveland’s most notable destination neighborhoods like Tremont, Gordon Square, and the Waterloo Arts District. Artists and creative businesses are often the driving forces and pioneers for these redevelopment efforts. We recommend a coordinated effort to mitigate gentrification and the displacement of the creative people and businesses in these and other developing areas.
5a. Work within community development programs and policies to extend support to artists and creative businesses
5b. Invest in arts spaces for necessary accessibility-related infrastructure updates
5c. consider a reduced tax rate for the sale of artwork and tax abatements for renovation
5d. Consider piloting programs to standardize wages and guarantee basic income for creative workers
5e. Address the admissions tax for small and mid-size music venues
5f. Reduce restrictive permitting and lessen bureaucracy for events, such as outdoor arts events, busking, and other publicly restricted arts activities
6: Work Closely with CMSD to Enhance Arts Education:
The Cleveland Metropolitan School District (CMSD) has committed $32M for Year 1 of a District-wide Arts Plan for K-12 students. We recommend the administration support the continuation of this new plan:
6a. Partner with CMSD’s Director of Arts Education and the Cleveland Arts Education Consortium
6b. Communicate with large and small arts organizations providing school programming to understand needs
6c. Support safe and equitable student access to these arts programs during out of school time
6d. Support the District’s tech needs and purchase of visual art supplies and musical instruments
7: Brand Cleveland as an Arts City:
7a. Partner with Destination Cleveland and Assembly for the Arts to expand and better define arts promotion
7b. Include arts and culture prominently on the City’s website
7c. Promote a developed narrative that speaks to the power of arts and culture and its importance within the city and across sectors
The following items are recommended as priority goals for the City Arts and Culture Liaison and corresponding staff structure.
Quarterly Assemblies
With a vision of ensuring that everyone benefits from a diverse and equitable arts and culture sector, we invite the people of Greater Cleveland to assemble for our quarterly state of the arts.
Quarterly Assemblies
Stay up to date on the most recent creative-industry-wide information over a meal and good company. Each quarter, we share updates on industry data trends, public policy, artist funding, racial equity initiatives, and more. As Assembly continues its work to expand resources and increase equity in Cleveland’s arts and culture scene, weigh-in on what you’d like to see. Share your voice and join the discussion by offering feedback. This event is for anyone, whether you work directly or indirectly with the arts industry. Attendees typically include artists, arts administrators, creative businesses, public officials, and anyone interested in connecting with the arts and cultural industries.
Each Assembly is held a different venue each month. Sign up for the Cadence to get receive updates on content and location as we approach the date.
And as always, if you have time after the discussion, stick around with us and continue networking with the amazing folks in our creative fields.
2024 Assemblies
(tentative schedule)
Thursday, March 7, 11:30 a.m. – 1 p.m., at moCa
Wednesday, June 5, 6-7:30 pm., The Hildebrandt Building
Thursday, September 5, (cancelled)
Wednesday, December 11, 6-7:30 pm., Artfully Phi Gallery
Quarterly meetings are $15 and include a lunch or dinner. Members attend for free; login before you register. Topics of each Assembly vary as we shift direction, services, advocacy, and organizational output to meet community needs.
